Guidance for Estimating Reductions & Cost
A key consideration in your submission will be the expected cost per ton of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) that your project reduces or sequesters. Below we provide guidance for estimating tons reduced and cost per ton. Please feel free to submit back-of-the-envelope estimates, and ranges if there are substantial uncertainties. Provide what you can; most importantly, we're interested in hearing your idea.
Estimating emissions reductions and carbon sequestration
Please provide back-of-the-envelope estimates of the total expected emissions reduced or carbon sequestered from your proposed project along with the reductions/sequestration you expect each year through the project lifetime. Please also provide a high-level description of the methods and major assumptions you used in your estimates, including a discussion of the baseline.
If you are not already familiar with estimating emission reductions from your project you might consult existing offset methodologies. You would not need to do all of the detailed calculations in those methodologies, but could apply the overall approach to your project.
Estimating $/ton CO2e
Cost per ton is a measure of the funds needed to enable the proposed project to be implemented and to operate. This measure gives UC an understanding of the funding needed by UC to generate the expected emissions reductions.
Please include your cost per ton estimate (which can be a range) and a discussion of the major costs over the project lifetime (upfront and operational), taking into account any revenues other than the sale of offsets.
You can download the template here.
The template is set up to estimate, at a high-level, the cost of offsets per ton of CO2e emissions avoided or sequestered. The idea is to capture the funds needed to create the offsets from project implementation to its final year of operations. The template automatically calculates net cost per ton each year of the project life and the levelized cost per ton CO2e for the project as a whole.
At the top of the template are “Summary Calculations,” which are based on inputs provided below under “Detailed Line Items.” You can enter your estimates in either section.
For project implementation costs (design, construction, initial supplies, etc.) please sum all of these expenses and provide them under year “0.” In some cases a project may have other sources of funds such as grants - these funds should be included as revenues to the degree that they are part of the offset project.
Many projects will not have revenues. Examples of projects with revenues are those that involve producing a product that is sold, like electricity or biogas. Other grants can also be considered as revenues as could the sale of replaced equipment.
The net cost of implementing and operating the offset project may be only the incremental increase in cost above the baseline scenario. For example, the costs of implementing a high efficiency boiler might only be the difference in costs between the high efficiency boiler and a standard boiler that would otherwise have been needed to replace an old boiler. These costs might be lessened over time by cost savings from the more efficient system. If avoided costs affect the funds needed to implement and operate the project, you can enter avoided costs in the Avoided Costs section.
If your project idea has multiple phases or is a pilot for a larger project, as possible, please estimate the cost per ton for each phase. You can do this in a single spreadsheet that includes both/all phases, or in separate spreadsheets.
The project life will differ per project. We have included twenty columns for input, for twenty years of the project life. Feel free to use only some of those columns if the project life is shorter than twenty years, or to add columns if it is longer.
The default discount rate is 6.5%, UC's capital planning rate.
Feel free to add rows or sections as needed to fit your project, as well as to use the space at the bottom as a worksheet.
We have been asked what our target $/ton range is. We are still exploring the costs of high quality offsets on the voluntary market, which we would compare with the costs of UC-initiated offset projects. This is an on-going exploration, but here is what we understand so far. High quality offsets can be found on the market in the $3 to $20 range. We will take into account the direct benefits of UC-initiated offset projects to UC including research and education benefits when weighing projects against one another.
Main project contact
We welcome cross-campus and cross-department collaborations as well as collaboration between UC and other institutions. For projects with multiple leads, free to include more than one main project contact.
Employees at the Lawrence Berkeley Natural Lab are considered to be UC employees.
Award amount you are requesting, up to $70,000
A total of $350,000 will be awarded to potential UC-initiated offset projects in awards of up to $70,000 each. The purpose of these awards is to help bring potential offset projects closer to implementation as per the needs of each project. Not all projects will receive the maximum amount, $70,000. We invite you to name several amounts that would be meaningful for your project, and what you could accomplish with each amount. For example, you could specify what you could accomplish with a $20,000 award, a $45,000 award, and a $70,000 award. What is meaningful will differ substantially among projects of different sizes and types. You also do not need to request award funds if you are only interested in being considered for future payments in line with the quantity of reductions your project will produce.
Funds do not need to be spent by a certain date, but we expect that most of the funds awarded will be used during the 2020 calendar year.
In addition, we may recommend several project proposals for award funds for the 2020-21 academic year. The reason we may be able to offer award funds for two years for this single call is due to the extended application process for some categories of CNI funds for the 2020-21 academic year that could be applied to offsets.
Feel free to attach additional information as appendixes to the submission if you believe that additional information will aid the review committee in understanding your project.
Please do not include any confidential information in your submission.
For reproductive health projects
We are researching methods for estimating the emissions impacts of reproductive health programs. If you are considering to submit a project idea that involves reproductive health, please be in touch with Barbara Haya (firstname.lastname@example.org).
For projects that involve planting trees
We will summarize methods for estimating carbon sequestration from tree planting here shortly.
We will continue to add information to this guidance as we receive questions, so feel free to check back here as you prepare your submission.